Few characters are as iconic as Mario. Since debuting in Donkey Kong (1981) and starring in Super Mario Bros. on the Nintendo Entertainment System (NES) in 1985, the plumber has defined gaming. Hollywood has adapted his adventures twice: first with the infamous 1993 live-action movie, and more recently with the 2023 animated blockbuster. How do the films compare to the games, and which one best captures the Mushroom Kingdom spirit?

The Games: Where It All Began

The original Super Mario Bros. for NES set the foundation for modern platformers. Bright worlds, creative power-ups, and precise platforming combined to create timeless gameplay. Over the years, titles like Super Mario 64, Super Mario Galaxy, and Super Mario Odyssey expanded the formula, offering players open worlds, inventive mechanics, and boundless charm.

Central to every game is its playful tone: simple yet challenging levels, memorable villains like Bowser, and the heroic duo Mario and Luigi rescuing Princess Peach. That blend of fun and accessibility is what kept the franchise fresh for decades.

The 1993 Live-Action Film

The 1993 movie reimagined Mario’s universe in a drastically different way. Starring Bob Hoskins and John Leguizamo, the film set the brothers in a dystopian alternate dimension where King Koopa ruled. The tone was gritty, mixing cyberpunk aesthetics with campy humor.

Fans expecting Mushroom Kingdom whimsy instead got dark sets, reptilian villains, and a story barely tied to the games. Though a commercial failure, it earned cult status for its odd, experimental vision.

The 2023 Animated Blockbuster

In contrast, the 2023 animated film fully embraced Nintendo’s source material. With Chris Pratt voicing Mario, Anya Taylor-Joy as Peach, and Jack Black as Bowser, the movie recreated the Mushroom Kingdom in vivid detail. Power-ups, Rainbow Road, and even the “DK Rap” made appearances.

This version leaned into nostalgia, offering Easter eggs and faithful visuals that delighted longtime fans. Its colorful, family-friendly tone matched the spirit of the games, making it a box office hit and a fan favorite.

Comparing Tone and Faithfulness

• Games: Whimsical, bright, and endlessly replayable, with platforming challenges and creative worlds.

• 1993 Film: Dark, campy, and experimental, straying far from Nintendo’s intent.

• 2023 Film: Faithful, nostalgic, and family-friendly, closely aligned with the games’ energy and design.

The games provided the blueprint, and the 2023 movie finally honored it on the big screen.

Final Verdict: Which One Wins?

If you enjoy quirky cult cinema, the 1993 film remains an oddball curiosity. If you want the Mushroom Kingdom brought to life with accuracy and charm, the 2023 adaptation is the clear winner. Yet, at the core, it’s the games themselves that continue to define Mario’s legacy—offering the interactivity, challenge, and joy no movie can fully replicate.

 Watch Super Mario Bros. (1993) on Youtube
Watch The Super Mario Bros. Movie (2023) on Amazon

Official Super Mario home from Nintendo

Love Game-to-Screen Comparisons?

Follow our weekly series where we explore legendary games and their film or TV adaptations. Next week, we’ll tackle Twisted Metal—from chaotic car combat to its Peacock streaming series.