1. Faxanadu (1987)
Price range: $20–$40 (loose cartridge)
A side-scrolling action RPG with fantastic world-building, Faxanadu flies under the radar compared to Zelda or Metroid. Its cult following means it’s sought after, but it’s still surprisingly affordable. Looking to add Faxanadu to your collection? We currently have a complete copy (cartridge, box, and manual) available. Check it out here.
2. Shingen the Ruler (1990)
Price range: $15–$30
This samurai-era strategy game is one of the NES’s more unique offerings. Because it’s a strategy title (less mainstream), prices haven’t spiked like other rarities, but collectors love finding it.
3. Little Nemo: The Dream Master (1990)
Price range: $25–$45
A Capcom platformer that didn’t get the same hype as DuckTales or Mega Man. Gorgeous visuals, inventive gameplay — and still within reach for most collectors.
4. The Guardian Legend (1989)
Price range: $30–$50
A hybrid of top-down shooter and Zelda-like exploration. It’s unique and didn’t sell as much as mainstream hits, keeping it rare but reasonably priced.
5. Snake Rattle 'n' Roll (1990)
Price range: $20–$35
Developed by Rare before they made Donkey Kong Country, this quirky isometric platformer is fun, colorful, and still affordable. It’s gaining more collector interest every year.
Bonus Pick: Disney’s DuckTales (1989)
Price range: $25–$45
While not as rare as some of the other titles on this list, Disney’s DuckTales is a standout NES game that’s still affordable and incredibly fun to collect. Developed by Capcom, it offers tight platforming and catchy music that’s made it a favorite for generations. It’s a perfect addition to any NES shelf without breaking the bank. Disney’s DuckTales is always in demand, and we’re lucky to have a complete copy in stock right now. View it here.
Tips for Finding NES Gems Without Overpaying
Shop local retro stores. Unlike eBay, local stores often price based on what moves inventory, not on bidding wars.
Look for bundle deals. Buying small lots can score you multiple affordable titles at once.
Inspect labels and pins. Make sure they’re authentic; reproduction carts have flooded the market.
Don’t wait too long. NES prices overall continue to climb year over year, which you can see by checking guides like PriceCharting that track actual game sales.
Ready to Hunt?
At Game Repair, we stock and hunt down rare NES titles all the time. Whether you’re looking to pick up one of these affordable gems, get your console cleaned up, or just nerd out about retro gaming, stop by our store or check out our inventory online.
Browse our NES games here or contact us if you’re searching for something special.